Posts tagged ‘Rights of Indigenous Peoples’
Toward a Right to Development? : Reflecting on the Endorois Decision
Last month, the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (“ACHPR”) handed down a decision on the Endorois peoples’ situation in Kenya. The decision not only marks the end of a nearly 40 year struggle by the Endorois people against the Kenyan government but it also heralds the increasing importance of the third generation human right to development.
The Endorois people are a sub-tribe from central Kenya that were evicted from their lands near Lake Bogoria in the 1970s. The government relocated them to an area that limited their access to a clean water source, central sites of worship and other daily requirements for their pastoral way of life. The Kenyan government failed to provide compensation for this eviction but still proceeded to develop a Game Reserve on the Endorois former lands.
After exhausting all domestic avenues for remedy, the Endorois – with the help of Minority Rights Group International – brought their case before the ACHPR. The ACHPR is a quasi-judicial regional body that renders non-binding decisions aimed at protecting human and collective rights in Africa as envisaged by the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights (“African Charter”). Although non-binding, I believe that the decisions from the ACHPR can be viewed as a snapshot of general zeitgeist. Indeed, until the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights starts delivering decisions regularly, the Commission’s decisions will remain…
Canada Actively Less-than-Active on Aboriginal Rights in the International Scene
September 13, 2007, was a day like any other, full of political brouhahas from the various corners of the world: then-President Bush addressed the nation on the way forward in Iraq; North Ireland introduced a cattle ear tags numbering system;[1] and Canada voted against the adoption of the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.
The Declaration put before the United Nations that day was the result of a process that started in 1985 with the UN Working Group on Indigenous People, given the broadly defined mandate to “give attention to the evolution of international standards concerning indigenous rights”. The general contents of the Declaration include “both individual and collective rights, cultural rights and identity, rights to education, health, employment, language, and others”. The final vote at United Nations General Assembly that day tallied 143 countries voting in favour of the Declaration, 11 abstentions, and 4 against (Canada, United States, New Zealand, and Australia). While Canada has made various strides in recognizing the rights of its aboriginal peoples, its vote on September 13 provides an example how an overly conservative and protectionist mindset can lead us a step backwards in recognizing the historical wrong-doings to a significant part of Canada’s population.
The Canadian Government provided two broad reasons for voting against the Declaration. The first reason was procedural. During the drafting stage of the Declaration, Canada…
